Jon Sumrall’s first Florida team needs to accomplish more than what's been predicted

Like any new coach, Jon Sumrall is going to have a bit of a honeymoon phase at Florida, especially considering how the previous five years have gone in Gainesville. Even Billy Napier went 6-7 in his maiden voyage and didn’t draw the ire of Gator Nation right away.

Vegas had Florida projected at 7.5 wins, and a new projection from CBS Sports also had Sumrall going 7-5 in 2026.

The question mark Florida fans need to ask themselves is whether a 7-5 campaign would be good enough in 2026.

CBS projects Florida to finish 7-5 under Jon Sumrall

Brad Crawford of CBS Sports did a prediction of every new Power Four coach, and he thinks the Gators will go 7-5 this year. Of Florida and Sumrall, he says:

“Sumrall's inaugural campaign at Florida comes with little margin for error. The Gators could face six ranked opponents, a daunting path for a new staff installing its systems and establishing a different identity. Sumrall hopes much of that work is accomplished before the SEC opener at Auburn.

Florida should be physical, disciplined and dangerous at home, but lulls are inevitable as players adjust and Sumrall learns to navigate the league's weekly pressure. This roster is capable of reaching eight wins, though a 7-5 finish feels more appropriate given the schedule. Growing pains should not diminish optimism; they are part of Florida's climb.”

Seven wins would look suspiciously familiar at Florida

This isn’t a commentary on whether 7-5 is a good prediction or not. We have stated Florida could finish 10-2 or 6-6, and neither would shock us. We would argue that Florida’s roster is good enough for ten wins if everything goes right, but concerns along the offensive line could dampen that enthusiasm.

But the argument we have been starting to make is that while 6-6 or 7-5 is definitely in the realm of possibility for Sumrall, he needs to go at least 8-4 or better to prove that he is going to last in Gainesville. 

The problem with going 7-5 this year is that while Florida wouldn’t necessarily have a “bad” loss, it wouldn’t have many “good” wins.

The most straightforward pathway to 7-5 would be:

Wins - FAU, Campbell, Auburn, South Carolina, Kentucky, Vanderbilt, and FSU

Losses - Ole Miss, Missouri, Texas, Georgia, and Oklahoma

It’s not a disaster, and Florida can build from that, but there would be very little from that to indicate that the Gators have taken a meaningful step forward. 7-5 means that for the sixth season in a row, Florida finishes unranked.

This is why we have 8-4 as the acceptable floor for Sumrall in 2026. It creates a pathway that Florida either:

A - Didn’t pick up a win against any of the big dogs in the SEC, but they at least beat everyone they should have.

B - If they do lose to a team or two they probably shouldn’t have, they at least countered it with wins over top-tier teams.

Our main argument is that we shouldn’t act like this is an untalented roster that can only win seven games. This team is capable of 10-2 if things go correctly. 

All we know is that we are excited for things to get going for real so that we can properly judge things on the field and not just hypothetical scenarios. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow