Florida's had a roller coaster season under Jon Sumrall in his first season in Gainesville. The Gators have upset wins over Ole Miss, Texas and Kentucky, but have bad losses to Missouri, South Carolina and Oklahoma.
The Gators are on track to have a strong finish to the season, sitting at 6-4 with two regular-season games remaining against Vanderbilt and Florida State, as well as a bowl game. While it's a bit disappointing to fans who thought the Gators could crash the College Football Playoff in Sumrall's first season. But this team can finish out on a high note at the end of the season.
Unlike Sumrall, one head coach that was expected to absolutely lead his team to the CFP during his first season was LSU head coach Lane Kiffin. The first-year Tigers head coach is one of the highest-paid head coaches in the nation making $13 million annually, and LSU spent an estimated $40-50 million on its 2026 roster. Surprisingly, Sumrall bests Kiffin this season when looking at teams both head coaches have played.
Jon Sumrall has three wins over common opponents Lane Kiffin, LSU lost to. Both coaches defeated Auburn
As one Florida fan pointed out, Florida and LSU share some common opponents. Most notably, both teams played Ole Miss, Texas, Kentucky as well as Auburn this season.
Sumrall's Florida team beat Ole Miss 52-28, Texas 27-24 and Kentucky 21-14. LSU and Coach Kiffin's team lost to those same teams, including a 32-24 loss to Ole Miss, a 35-24 overtime loss to Kentucky and a 22-21 loss to Texas this past weekend.
Both head coaches were able to get wins over Auburn, also led by first-year head coach Alex Golesh. The Tigers are 6-4 on the season. Florida beat Auburn on the road 44-39 in Week 3, and LSU defeated Auburn 38-17 at the end of October.
LSU, Lane Kiffin Result | Common Opponent | Florida, Jon Sumrall Result |
|---|---|---|
38-17 win | Auburn | 44-39 win |
32, 24 loss | Ole Miss | 52-28 win |
35-34 loss | Kentucky | 21-14 win |
22-21 loss | Texas | 27-24 win |
Jon Sumrall explains heated exchange he had with Florida OL coach Phil Trautwein
This is all a bit ironic given that around this time last year, Kiffin was heavily linked to the open Florida job. The Gators reportedly strongly pursued Kiffin until it became clear that the head coach had set his sights on taking the LSU job. Sumrall initially cancelled a meeting with Florida before Scott Stricklin made him his main target after missing on Kiffin.
Kiffin's first season in Baton Rouge has fallen well below expectations, as LSU is just 6-4 and squarely out of the CFP hunt. The Tigers surprisingly also now have the same record as Florida with games against Tennessee and Arkansas remaining. Florida still has to play Vanderbilt and Florida State, so LSU and Florida won't share anymore common opponents the rest of the season.
Of course, there's no way to know which head coach hire will be more successful at both schools after just one season. But Sumrall besting Kiffin against the majority of common opponents the head coaches have played against might be a positive sign.
ALSO READ: Why eight wins would matter at Jon Sumrall's first season at Florida

