When the playoff committee came out with their rankings this week, there was plenty of outcry from those around college football. The two main contentions were Alabama at No. 3 and a host of 6-4 SEC teams, which included Florida, making up spots 20 through 25.
But as much as those around the country seem flabbergasted that a 6-4 Florida team is ranked, one could argue that, more than anything else, the committee is underranking the Gators.
Florida is stronger than what its 6-4 record indicates
The Big Ten Network, among others, started musing after the rankings came out that it was crazy that a number of 6-4 SEC teams were ranked ahead of all the 6-4 Big Ten teams. Big Ten fans love to point out that their conference has won the last three national titles, and while that is true, it ignores the reality that in 2026 the SEC is a far deeper conference than anyone else in the country.
"I think Iowa is the most disrespected team, not just in the Big Ten but of any team in the top 25."
— Big Ten Network (@BigTenNetwork) November 18, 2026
🗣️ Jake Butt on No. 15 Iowa pic.twitter.com/dME35zZ3NQ
In case one needs a reminder, the SEC is currently 10-2 in non-conference play against other Power Four conferences. None of the other Power Four conferences have a winning record. The SEC is also 18-0 against other non-Power Four teams. Every other conference has a loss against a non-Power Four team.
And it’s a big reason why, if anything else, the conference is being undervalued by the committee relative to the computer rankings. And if one is mad about Florida or Alabama or anyone else in the SEC being ranked as high as they are, then they haven’t been paying attention to the committee over the years.
We aren’t here to say the committee is perfect or that they even “know ball,” but one thing over the years that the committee has rewarded more than anything else are quality wins. For as much as FSU fans whine and moan over 2023 or UCF fans moan over 2017, the reality is that, at the end of the day, they didn’t have any quality wins.
To highlight this point, we ran our own computer model: we took the Massey Ratings computer rankings and gave points for every win a team has relative to that opponent’s ratings. Beating the No. 1 ranked team was worth 138 points and beating the No. 138 ranked team was worth one point.
The idea is to see which teams have the best quality wins and which teams are filled up with fluff. Nine of the top 11 teams in our highly unofficial HFH model are among the top 11 with the CFP committee, and three of the top four align. Alabama ranks No. 4 in this model, and it’s UCLA that sits at No. 6 because they haven’t beaten anyone of note.
The above complained about Iowa, who was ranked No.15, also comes in at No. 15 in our model.
Florida ranks No. 17 in this model, and their six wins have added up to more points than Wake Forest's nine wins and the seven wins Louisville, Duke, SMU, and Houston have.
The point is, Florida at No. 24 isn’t some conspiracy. The Gators have quality wins this year that a ton of other posturing 6-4 and 7-3 teams can’t claim.
No matter how they try to posture otherwise.

